Milburn pulls back from deep look at pupil experience in schools
The DWP, for whom Alan Milburn wrote his report. Image: iStock.
Some criticism of solely “knowledge-rich” schooling – as favoured by both the Conservatives and the Starmer government – but final report backs off analysis of impact on young people of school behaviour policies, and transition from primary to secondary, implied by interim report in May.
The Milburn report, which today sets out far-reaching plans for what is being billed as a “new deal” between young people and the state, appears to have pulled back from the deep look at pupils’ schooling experience which was glimpsed in his interim document six months ago.
On several aspects which the interim report flagged up as important to the earlier experiences of young people who go on to be classed as NEET (Not in education, employment or training), the final report offers no qualitative insights or recommendations.
These include the use of isolation rooms in schools, the emotional impact of the transition between primary and secondary education, and arguably what the interim report ventured may be an exclusionary effect of the assessment system on some children.
The report, which is garnering exhaustive coverage across the media for its proposals for a Youth Opportunity Service and other measures to turn around the UK’s European-outlier NEET rates, does push back against aspects of this government’s education inheritance from the Conservatives, including on solely “knowledge-rich” schooling approaches.
But there are also echoes of some New Labour approaches to education, including a national teaching strategy approach for English and, in the long term, the concept of an “integrated” qualifications framework for 14- to 19-year-olds and modular assessment. Milburn’s support for multi-academy trusts, which were not mentioned in the interim report, was to this observer a surprise, and may be an indication of some successful lobbying by high-profile backers of the policy.
Milburn’s emphasis on the moral obligation of policymakers to the next generation of young people, with such debate dominating the news today, was of course welcome. But this piece delves into the detail on education.
To continue reading this article…
You'll need to register with EDUCATION UNCOVERED. Registration is free and gives you access to one article per month. But please consider a subscription which will give you full access to all the news articles and analysis on the website. As a subscriber you'll also be able to comment on each news article. as well as support our journalism and extend the reach of the site.

By Warwick Mansell for EDUCATION UNCOVERED
Published: 17 November 2026

Comments
Submitting a comment is only available to subscribers.